Payment Center
Make a Payment
Have the Blue Marsh app? You can set billing reminders and pay your bill directly from our app! It’s quick, easy and FREE to download. Learn more and download it here.
Or you can click on your appropriate carrier below to pay your bill online. If you cannot find your appropriate company payment link below, please feel free to contact us directly.
Note: These links will take you to a website outside of the Blue Marsh Insurance website. The new site may offer a different privacy policy and level of security. Blue Marsh Insurance is not responsible for and does not endorse or guarantee the new site’s content.
For more information on life, health and disability payments, call (877) 627-7480 or click here.
AmTrust
Make An Online Payment
(877) 528-7878
ASI
Make An Online Payment
(866) 274-8765
Donegal Group
Make An Online Payment
(800) 877-0600
Erie Insurance
Make An Online Payment
(800) 458-0811
Foremost Insurance Group
Make An Online Auto Insurance Payment
Make An Online Home Insurance Payment
(888) 888-0080
Frederick Mutual
Make An Online Payment
(800) 544-8737
Grange Insurance
Make An Online Payment
(800) 425-1100
Hanover Insurance
Make An Online Payment
(800) 573-1187
Hagerty
Make An Online Payment
(800) 762-2628
MetLife
Make An Online Auto or Home Insurance Payment
(800) 638-5433
Pennsylvania Lumberman’s Insurance
Make An Online Payment
(800) 752-1895
Philadelphia Insurance
Make An Online Payment
(877) 438-7459
Plymouth Rock
Make An Online Payment
(855) 993-4470
Prudential
Make An Online Payment
(800) 778-2255
Progressive
Make An Online Payment
(855) 758-0943
Openly
(857) 990-9080
Safeco
Make An Online Payment
(888) 458-2246
Selective
Make An Online Payment
(888) 974-7400
The Hartford
Make An Online Personal Insurance Payment
Make An Online Business Insurance Payment
(877) 896-9320
Travelers
Make An Online Personal Insurance Payment
Make An Online Business Insurance Payment
(800) 842-5075
Selective
Make An Online Payment
(888) 974-7400